Elm Street Brewing Company: In the middle of basically nowhere (Muncie, IN), northeast of Indianapolis, you will find one of the most unique breweries in the Midwest. Elm Street is about as nondescript and charming as they come. I actually drove past it before I realized my mistake. It’s a converted something, and has developed into a place frequented mostly by locals, but perfectly welcoming to outsiders. The atmosphere is too hard to describe, so I won’t try, but it is definitely kid friendly, and they’ve got a nice food menu. I recall getting the chicken fingers, but there were a lot of options. There is a solid selection of IPAs, but clearly, they rotate frequently. I had The Cowboy Gets High… and the Citranot. I preferred the former, but both were excellent. (Updated 9.2026)
Myriad Brewing: Located in Newburgh, IN, very close to Evansville, IN and Henderson, KY, this local favorite has something for everyone. I was there on a Tuesday and fell ass backwards into a trivia night, narrowly avoiding the Wednesday night bingo crown. They have a full bar and a few non-local macrobrews, but have several great options on tap. I enjoyed the Golden Ratio IPA; very smooth, very flavorful. The proprietors themselves just opened an in-house kitchen, which looked well done, and they also support rotating local food trucks. There is a great outdoor area that is perfectly appropriate for kids. There aren’t a ton of local beer options in this area, so if you’re heading this way, don’t miss out.
